Posted by: Francis Koster Published: May 14, 2012

Is the Sustainability Movement Political Hype?

Is the Sustainability Movement Political Hype?

by Francis P. Koster, Ed.D.

"Scarce as hens' teeth" has little meaning to children who have never seen a live chicken and don't know chickens have no teeth. "Friending" someone on FACEBOOK is a word now in common use - but was unknown a few years ago. New words enter a society, and old ones fall out of use.

One of those new words is "sustainable". What the heck does it mean? And how does it apply to your life, and the life of your family? Is it just advertising hype?

The word means that you can keep on doing something forever. Unsustainable means you cannot.

There is economic sustainability - on a personal level, your household or local economy cannot spend more than it brings in. You cannot send more money out of the community to buy energy than the community brings in from another source. It is an unsustainable behavior.

And there is environmental sustainability - Your area cannot use or export more water than falls on it or you will drain your lakes and aquifer, and suffer. If we burn more polluting fossil fuels than the atmosphere can absorb and clean - human health will suffer. It is an unsustainable behavior.

And there is the sustainability of supply chains - if your food rides diesel trucks thousands of miles, the price of oil may impact the sustainability of that practice. Just look at your recent grocery bill. How long can you keep that up?

Sustainability is the recognition that there are limits - not to all growth, as was once thought, but rather to certain kinds of growth. If you don't practice sustainability, growth stops - often with a crash, and hurt.

Examples of unsustainable behavior are all around us – using chemicals which cause falling testosterone levels among men (down 45% over the last 16 years, according The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology).i Developing islands of plastic garbage bigger than Texas and growingii, in the middle of the oceans which kill our edible fish. School lunch programs which contribute to obesity in 1/3 of our children. These are unsustainable.

Communities around the country are taking steps to develop new behaviors.

One leader in this area is Burlington, Vermont. Burlington and its surrounding area have a population of around 200,000. Ten years ago Burlington had a handsome but fading small town downtown with lots of vacant store fronts, and a high unemployment rate. Sound familiar?

A group of citizens held a retreat to set up a roadmap for local sustainability. Among their goals were having a vibrant urban center, expanding local jobs, creating economic self reliance, and creation of a more robust local food supply. They issue an annual report on progress, and have every right to feel proud of themselves. Among other noteworthy accomplishments, local food production is up, and the number of empty buildings downtown is downiii. They had an unemployment rate of 3.8% in December of 2012iv, when the rest of the country was close to 9%v.

The Sustainability Office of Des Moines, Iowa had its Parks and Recreation staff cultivated the dormant land in neighborhood parks and around schools and community shelters. They planted fruits and nuts because once settled in they require considerably less maintenance than annual vegetable crops.

Des Moines’ reasons to turn public space into food gardens are profound: bolster food security, improve economic self-sufficiency, increase community access to nutritious food, encourage longevity and maintain the viability of the local food system. They want to make sure that the art and science of growing food do not vanish from their town as concern about sustainability of global food security

Both of these cities are regularly found on the "Best Places to live" lists – people move there because of the strong quality of life.

In other parts of the country, citizens came together to identify and fix older housing that has a lot of air leaks. For modest investment these homes are caulked and weatherized, reducing energy consumption 30% and keeping an average of $300 per home per year in the local economy.vii Since these savings circulate, a big cash multiplier effect occurs in the local economy.

Each of these examples of sustainability resulted in lower costs to citizens, higher employment, a healthier population, increased knowledge base, and peace of mind in the face of the threats created by unsustainable practices elsewhere. These examples can all be copied.

Sustainability is not hype - it is common sense that only seems uncommon because it is not practiced as widely as it could be. We can change that.

i Travison, TG, AB Araujo, AB O’Donnell, V Kupelian, JB McKinlay. 2007. A population-level decline in serum testosterone levels in American men. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism 92:196–202.

Copyright © 2020 The Optimistic Futurist. All Rights Reserved.

Francis P. Koster Ed.D.

Proven local solutions to national problems.


Francis P. Koster, Ed. D.

1012 Westlake Drive

Kannapolis, NC 28081

Copyright © 2023 America's Optimistic Futurist

Scroll to Top